Thursday, July 17, 2008

UK takes baby-steps, "allows" self-defense

From not-so-Great Britain, comes this news:
Home owners and “have-a go-heroes” have for the first time been given the legal right to defend themselves against burglars and muggers free from fear of prosecution.

They will be able to use force against criminals who break into their homes or attack them in the street without worrying that "heat of the moment” misjudgements could see them brought before the courts.

Under new laws police and prosecutors will have to assess a person’s actions based on the person’s situation "as they saw it at the time” even if in hindsight it could be seen as unreasonable.

For example, homeowners would be able stab or shoot a burglar if confronted or tackle them and use force to detain them until police arrive. Muggers could be legally punched and beaten in the street or have their own weapons used against them.
Amazing how far the Brits have been emasculated by their government and legal system, that the above is an improvement to their current system.

The article notes that even these modest changes have been opposed by the current Labour government for years:
Mr Straw – and other Labour ministers – have previously repeatedly blocked attempts by opposition MPs to give greater protection to householders.

In 2004 Tony Blair promised to review the existing legislation after he admitted there was "genuine public concern” about the issue.

But his pledge was dropped weeks later after the then Home Secretary Charles Clarke concluded that the current law was "sound”.

Two Private Member’s Bills on the issue were tabled by the Tories around the time of the 2005 general election, but both were sunk by the Government.

In 2004, a Tory Bill designed to give the public the right to forcibly tackle burglars was also rejected.
The BritGov's longstanding position is that British subjects should not defend themselves, but should rely on the government to protect them. However, the article notes
"These changes in the law will make clear – victims of crime, and those who intervene to prevent crime, should be treated with respect by the justice system. We do not want to encourage vigilantism, but there can be no justice in a system which makes the victim the criminal."

It came as it emerged that homeowners could have to wait up to three days after reporting a crime to see a police officer, according to a leaked draft of the Policing Green Paper.

It sets out new national standards for local policing for all 43 forces cross England and Wales.

Callers to the police will be given set times within which officers will attend an incident.

The paper says that this will be "within three hours it if requires policing intervention or three days if there is less immediate need for a police presence."

So, homeowners have to wait up to three hours for a situation that "requires policing intervention", or up to three days "if there is less immediate need for a police presence". And this is an improvement from the current situation. Scary.

1 comment:

Mulligan said...

prosecution of the victim is what you get when the law is controlled by people who don't have to walk anywhere without bodyguards. royalty uh, i mean lawmakers, are obviously out of touch with the common man's problems.